There are a few different types of dog training collars on the market to consider for your pup. These collars can be invaluable tools when training dogs, but some people express concerns about their potential for causing harm.

When using the right collar, pet owners can reinforce verbal commands, protect their dog’s well-being, and build a positive relationship with their dog. Choosing the right tools to help you train your pup is essential, so let’s explore the different types of dog training collars and whether they are effective and humane.

Types of Dog Training Collars

There are a few popular dog training collars that are marketed as tools for training dogs. These collars include:

Electric Collars

Also called electronic collars, e-collars, or shock collars, these devices typically work with a remote that allows owners to deliver an electronic stimulation, often described as a buzz, tingle, or mild shock to the dog when a specific behavior is exhibited.

Proponents of e-collars often cite their effectiveness in training dogs, particularly for off-leash obedience, behavior modification, and addressing specific problems such as excessive barking or chasing.

However, we have found that these collars don’t allow owners to provide personalized instructions to the dog. We don’t recommend them to our clients because of this and their potential for abuse.

Harnesses

Harnesses are generally used to teach dogs to pull, so they aren’t a great training tool for most dogs. However, we will use and recommend harnesses for dogs that cannot tolerate traditional collars, such as those with weak tracheas. These are generally brachycephalic breeds or those that can have difficulty breathing, such as bulldogs, boxers, shar-peis, pugs, and some mastiff breeds.

Flat (or Martingale) Collars

Flat collars, also called martingale collars, have an adjustable loop that tightens if the dog pulls on their leash, making it difficult for them to slip out of their collars. 

These collars are different from choke collars in that they cannot choke a dog if properly adjusted and fitted. Therefore, they have much less risk of abuse than e-collars or choke collars, and they allow most people to handle their dogs well and develop their relationship with their pup without conflict.

We use martingale collars and recommend them to our clients because of their effectiveness, humaneness, and low risk of abuse.

Prong Collars 

Prong collars are designed to apply pressure to the dog’s neck when they pull on their leash. These collars aren’t intended to hurt the dog but to discourage them from continuing to pull. 

We only recommend prong collars for specific clients, such as for bigger, stronger, or less sensitive dogs or owners who are much smaller or physically weaker than their dogs.

Choosing the Right Training Collar for Your Dog

When evaluating the use of dog training collars, it’s essential to consider your dog’s individual background and needs.

Every dog is different and may respond differently to certain training methods. Factors such as breed, temperament, and previous training experiences should be considered when determining the most appropriate training approach for any given dog.

It’s important to choose a training collar that supports your dog’s well-being and your relationship with your dog for long-term success, and a professional trainer can help you do this.

Get Personalized Collar Recommendations With Nova Pack Dog Training

Ultimately, the decision on whether to use dog training collars should be made after thorough consideration of all training options, talking with a professional trainer, and considering your dog’s unique needs. Learn which collar would work best for you and your dog by scheduling a training consultation with Nova Pack Dog Training!